top of page

Science vs Mysticism

Oct 24
3 min read

This whole blog should be read to the tune of "Anything you can do I can do better." Why? Because it really encapsulates the whole science vs mysticism in superhero genre books, comics and films.


Take a wizard. He casts a spell using his 'magic' to effect a cone of cold. How is that different to the superhero who causes a blast of frozen ice from his fingers. Where did that come from? Was the superhero using magic? The books suggest otherwise, yet the results are pretty much the same.


In the book 'Fid's Crusade' one of the superheroes uses freezing cold, by opening a pinpoint hole to a frozen planet in another dimension, which allows freezing cold to rush out. The issue is not that he is opening a portal to another realm but how is he managing to do it in the first instance? You or I could wave our hands about and think mighty thoughts, but it doesn't open holes in space (well at least I am claiming my thoughts don't).

In D&D, a wizard can cast a ray of frost using his magic (assuming he has learnt the spell and has the suitable components) but what is the magic doing? How does some materials and spoken words affect the surroundings to bring about the cold formation?


I would contend that in both cases, the main element involved in a change in reality that allows the effects to occur. Both require mental application - one to force open the pinhole in space and the other to shape the magic to a specific outcome.


More broadly, super powers are inexplicable. Oh, you can call them mutations. You can say they come from super science. You can say the fundamental laws of physics have changed and people can harness these, but that is just sophistry. They (mostly) cannot function in the ways we see (with the possible exception of robotic and technological inventions).


There is one caveat to this - mind enhanced powers (telepathy and mental control, telekinesis and the like); these could be explained by mental powers that could stem from mutations in the brain or some such. But then again, telekinesis as carried out by a super powered human is little different to the D&D spell to create a 'Mage Hand' that can lift things.


So if the above is right, that both mystical powers and superhero powers are similar, why do we bother distinguishing one from the other at all?


I would suggest that while super powers generally as seen in comics are inherent to the person or caused by changes to the normal human condition, allowing them to interact with the environment (including their own bodies) to make changes to the surrounds, magic powers require some form of external 'gift' or grant of powers which could be removed. Certainly, if a spell is derived from an external source that is granting the lone of a power, then it almost certainly is a conditional grant. Examples of this abound in comics, but as a single example here, think 'The Juggernaut' in Marvel Comics who gets his powers from Cyttorak, a Godlike mystic entity. The entity has withdrawn his power on occasion, so it is demonstrably conditional.


This is also true of D&D cleric and paladin spells, which channel their chosen God's energies and can be withheld if the God so wishes. Less clear cut are mage spells, as they use 'magical' energies, but these seem to require refreshing over time and regular studying of the spell to ensure it is 'fixed' in the mind.


If this is true, then for story purposes, what should we take as the main lesson from science vs mystic powers?


Well, for my own story (lets bring this brief blog back to the Harbinger Six world - spoiler alert here), I am placing the powers in the scientific side of origins, with mutations allowing powers to manifest. These mutations are a result of exotic matter bathing the subject who has appropriate 'Meta Genes' to express as new super powers. But how the exotic matter comes about and why is there a distinct order v chaos element to the expressed powers - well that is where mysticism may sit.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Harbinger Six - What happens next

I thought I should take time out from the NovNov work, to quickly update people on what I think will happen with regards to the first book Rise of the Bane. The draft sits half complete - 28 chapters

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page